Hire a web team, use an agency, or partner? Here is how they compare.
Hiring gives you a whole team, at several times the cost and a quarter of hiring. An agency gives you a metered slice through a ticket queue. A partnership embeds a senior team that owns the whole website from week one, for one flat monthly fee.
The short answer
Each option is right for a different situation
Here is when we would recommend each, including the three that are not us.
Hire in house when the website is the product
If you need a permanent team of several specialists for years, build it. Expect a team of four to run well past $40K a month fully loaded and a quarter to hire before it ships anything.
Use an agency for a defined project
A redesign with a fixed scope and an end date is what agencies do well. Metered capacity through a ticket queue suits a project, not a website that has to keep moving every week.
Keep a vendor stack for point tools
SEO, CRO, and hosting vendors each cover a slice. Nobody owns how the slices fit together, so you become the project manager, which is usually where the website stalls.
Choose the partnership when the website needs an owner
When Marketing answers for a channel nobody runs, a senior team embedded in your channels, with twelve standing responsibilities and a named lead, replaces the headcount you would otherwise hire. See how it works.
Side by side
The four ways teams buy web capability today
An in-house team holds the whole, at several times the cost. Agencies and vendor stacks each cover a slice. The partnership holds the whole, for one flat fee.
| Criteria | The partnership | In-house team | Agency retainer | Vendor stack |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strategy, design, development, AI search and analytics in one team | Yes | Sometimes | No | No |
| Producing in week one, not after a quarter of hiring | Yes | No | Sometimes | Sometimes |
| A named lead accountable for the whole website | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| One flat monthly cost, no hiring or management overhead | Yes | No | Sometimes | No |
| AI search (GEO) inside the engagement, not a separate SKU | Yes | No | No | No |
| Attribution wired from first touch to revenue | Yes | Sometimes | No | No |
| You own every asset, account and line of code | Yes | Yes | Sometimes | Sometimes |
| Scales up or down without hiring or firing | Yes | No | Sometimes | Yes |
Strategy, design, development, AI search and analytics in one team
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- Sometimes
- Agency retainer
- No
- Vendor stack
- No
Producing in week one, not after a quarter of hiring
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- No
- Agency retainer
- Sometimes
- Vendor stack
- Sometimes
A named lead accountable for the whole website
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- Yes
- Agency retainer
- No
- Vendor stack
- No
One flat monthly cost, no hiring or management overhead
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- No
- Agency retainer
- Sometimes
- Vendor stack
- No
AI search (GEO) inside the engagement, not a separate SKU
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- No
- Agency retainer
- No
- Vendor stack
- No
Attribution wired from first touch to revenue
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- Sometimes
- Agency retainer
- No
- Vendor stack
- No
You own every asset, account and line of code
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- Yes
- Agency retainer
- Sometimes
- Vendor stack
- Sometimes
Scales up or down without hiring or firing
- The partnership
- Yes
- In-house team
- No
- Agency retainer
- Sometimes
- Vendor stack
- Yes
FAQ
What teams ask when they compare
Cost, ownership, and when the other options are the better call.
Still comparing? Bring your situation to a 30-minute call.
We will tell you which option fits, including when it is hiring or an agency rather than us.